The best gifts for Virgos can be tricky to find because, as the sign of service, they likely won’t be shouting their birthday wish lists from every social media account (cough, cough, Leo). As an earth sign ruled by communication planet Mercury (like the air sign Gemini), Virgos have a reputation for being perfectionists who love to organize. Okay, so it’s somewhat true for a few people born under this astrological sign’s season, which runs from August 23 through September 22. That’s why we included an already-organized set of gel eyeliners from ColourPop and an eyelash extension-friendly eye mask from Slip.

With that being said, people born under the Virgo zodiac sign are also creative, intelligent, and giving. They are so much more than their perfection-striving stereotype, and they’re more than willing to embrace their laidback, funny, and imperfect sides — when the time is fitting, of course. Not to mention, Virgos’s affinity for details makes them cosmically-inclined gift-givers, so chances are they gave you an awesome present at some point.

Still worried about what to get someone with the same sign as Beyoncé? We got you. Click through our Virgo gift guide for presents to make them swoon.