Jennifer Lopez definitely has a manicure comfort zone. The star loves a nude or nude-adjacent set, which makes sense given her super-busy schedule; she’s always hopping between premieres and photoshoots and press appearances, so she needs a manicure that can work with any outfit, any time. (She’s also known for her longtime love of the classic nude lip.) While Lopez does dabble in other shades from time to time, the nude nail is her go-to, but she flipped the script for the Wicked premiere in favor of something a little more magical and mystical.

For the Los Angeles premiere of the Broadway musical-turned-movie, Lopez gave her milky manis and nude nails the night off in favor of what manicurist Tom Bachik called a “moonstone” manicure, reminiscent of the mesmerizing gemstone. The shade itself was still soft and subtle, but instead of a pinky-white or skin-tone shade, Lopez and Bachik opted for a cool, shape-shifting, ultra-pale blue. To get the look, Bachik applied Après Nail’s Gel-X extensions in a squared-off coffin shape, then used a chrome powder atop the extension for that lit-from-within glow.